Recently, your very own winemonkey randomly stocked up the mini wine fridge with some under $10 quaffers. With a little bit of fond memory attached to the purchases, I chose to toss in Bonny Doon's 2004 Big House Red and 2005 Big House White. (I mean you can't drink First Growths everyday, right...hmmm.....actually, no, you can, I just can't afford to.)
Now, much can be said of eccentric winemaker and Bonny Doon owner Randall Grahm. His eclectic marketing style along with solid wines put him on the value map a long time ago. Last summer Grahm sold off his Big House and Cardinal Zin Brands to The Wine Group, LLC so I was interested to see what the last of his wines from these fun value brands would taste like. Sadly, disappointment reigned.
Was this my inevitable change of palate? Could I no longer appreciate a value brand? Was my conversion to wine snobbery so complete that I could not tolerate anything with a screwcap? Thankfully, no, no and no. Good wine is good wine regardless of pedigree and bad wine is bad wine just the same. I've had expensive, well-heeled bottles from all of over that have been atrocious and on the flip side, my dive into the bargain bin pulled up a number of interesting finds including a $3.50 bottle of Primitivo that knocks the socks off these sorry Big House offerings. (Yeah $3.50)
No wine fans, it looks like Randall got out while the getting was good. I remember these wines as having some interest and for what it was, they were a fun little wine. That said, it has been probably over five years (and many thousands of bottles) since I have tasted the Big House Red, but I would have thought it would more or less be on auto control. I thought wrong. To ensure I was not going out of my mind, these bottles were also tasted by vino girl (who had it blind against another value wine), as well as some other "non-wine" folks who all came to the same conclusion- "bleeeeech!"
The red was, at best, over simplistic, tart and out of balance and, at worst, undrinkable. The white showed marginally better (meaning not offensive) with some pleasant flowery and white fruit aromas, but was utterly insipid in the mouth. My immediate thought was white wine flavored water. Plonk, plonk, plonk, plonk, plonk. Sheesh.
Frankly, my memory may be clouded (I did drink quite a bit back then) and these wines may have never lived up to expectations, but it is my feeling that this type of experience is why people don't "get" wine. They start off like all of us drinking random inexpensive bottles and get hit with swill after swill and soon go back to drinking beer and bringing mags of Yellow Tail to parties.
Fear not budding wine enthusiasts- there is better wine out there! Stay the course! It gets better, I promise!
These Big House wines can be had for around $10 virtually everywhere, but in my opinion skip 'em and buy the six pack.